English

Comparative Study of Resistance Spot Welding and Laser Spot Welding of Ultra High Strength Steel for Vehicles

116
2024-09-05 14:08:08
See translation

Researchers from Annamarai University in India and South Ural State University in Russia reported a comparative study of resistance spot welding and laser spot welding of ultra-high strength steel for automobiles. The related research was published in The International Journal of Lightweight Materials and Manufacturing under the title "A comparative study on resistance spot and laser beam spot welding of ultra high strength steel for automotive applications".

 



This study investigated the effects of resistance spot welding (RSW) and laser spot welding (LBSW) processes on the microstructure evolution, load-bearing capacity, heat affected zone (HAZ) softening, and corrosion resistance of ultra-high strength steel (UHSS) joints welded using lap design. A dual phase 1000 grade (UHSDP1000) ultra-high strength steel plate with a thickness of 1.20 millimeters was welded using response surface methodology (RSM) optimized RSW and LBSW parameters. The microstructure characteristics of the welding area of RSW and LBSW joints were studied using an optical microscope (OM). The load bearing capacity of RSW and LBSW joints was evaluated using tensile shear failure load (TSFL) and cross tensile failure load (CTFL) tests. The fracture surfaces of TSFL and CTFL test samples were observed using scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The microhardness distribution of the RSW and LBSW joint area was evaluated and attributed to the TSFL and CTFL failures of the joint. The corrosion resistance of RSW and LBSW joints was analyzed using potential corrosion and immersion corrosion tests. The TSFL and CTFL durability of RSW joints are 183% and 62.79% higher than those of LBSW joints, respectively. Due to the smaller bearing area, the TSFL and CTFL durability of LBSW joints is not as good as that of RSW joints. This leads to stress concentration in the FZ and HAZ of the LBSW joint. RSW and LBSW joints exhibit TSFL and CTFL failures in fracture mode, accompanied by HAZ tearing. The reason for the failure of RSW and LBSW joints in the heat affected zone is softening caused by martensitic tempering and grain coarsening. The corrosion resistance of LBSW joints is worse than that of RSW joints, due to the higher content of martensite, which increases the proportion of pitting sites and reduces the corrosion resistance.

 


Figure 1. Potential applications of UHSS in automotive structural frameworks.

 


Figure 2. a) Images of RSW and b) LBSW machines used for manufacturing joints.

 


Figure 3. RSWed UHSDP1000 steel joint image: a) TSFL; b) CTFL test samples.

 


Figure 4. LBSWed UHSDP1000 steel joint image: a) TSFL; b) CTFL test samples.

 


Figure 5. a) Tensile testing machine setup; b) TSFL test setup; c) CTFL test setup.

 


Figures 6 and 7 respectively show a schematic diagram of the electrochemical corrosion test (top image) and a picture of the test sample (bottom image).

 


Figure 8. Typical macro images of spot welded joints: a) RSW and b) LBSW.

 


Figure 9. a) Images of TSFL samples with broken RSW joints and b) LBSW joints.

 


Figure 10. a) CTFL sample images of RSW joint and b) LBSW joint rupture.

 


Figure 11. a) Transverse BM section; b) Optical microstructure of longitudinal BM cross-section.

 


Figure 12. Microstructure of UHSDP1000 steel spot welded joint in different regions: a) FZ of RSW joint, b) UC-HAZ, c) IC-HAZ, d) LC-HAZ, and e) FZ of LBSW joint f) UC-HAZ、g) IC-HAZ、h) LC-HAZ。

summary
1. The FZ microstructure of RSW joint shows the evolution of acicular ferrite, Flat noodles martensite and polygonal ferrite. Since the cooling rate of LBSW is faster than that of RSW, FZ of LBSW joint shows a finer lath martensite structure and a certain proportion of acicular ferrite.

2. Compared with the LBSW joint, the TSFL and CTFL durability of the RSW joint have been improved by 183% and 62.79%, respectively. Due to the relatively small load-bearing area, the TSFL and CTFL durability of LBSW joints is not as good as that of RSW joints. This leads to stress concentration in the FZ and softened HAZ of the LBSW joint.

3. RSW joint and LBSW joint fracture failure, UHSDP1000 steel tearing in HAZ. The RSW joint exhibits a ductile failure mode, while the LBSW joint shows a combination of ductile and brittle failure modes, due to stress concentration in the softened HAZ leading to more tearing on the HAZ side.

4. The HAZ hardness of RSW and LBSW joints has significantly decreased, leading to HAZ softening problems, mainly due to the presence of a large amount of martensite in the microstructure of UHSDP1000 steel.

5. The TSFL failure of RSW and LBSW joints in the HAZ is attributed to softening caused by martensitic tempering and grain coarsening in the HAZ.

6. Compared with RSW joints, LBSW joints have higher FZ hardness, mainly due to the finer martensitic microstructure in FZ.

7. The corrosion resistance of LBSW joints is lower than that of RSW joints, because the martensite content is higher, which is conducive to an increase in the proportion of pitting sites and a decrease in corrosion resistance.

Source: Yangtze River Delta Laser Alliance

Related Recommendations
  • In depth understanding of the formation of condensation rings in laser spot welding - machine learning and molecular dynamics simulation

    Researchers from the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory and Johns Hopkins University have reported that machine learning and molecular dynamics simulations can help to gain a deeper understanding of the formation of condensation rings in laser spot welding. The related paper titled 'Machine learning and molecular dynamics simulations aided insights into conditioned ring formation in laser spot ...

    2024-12-21
    See translation
  • Shanghai Optics and Machinery Institute has made new progress in laser welding of new high-temperature nickel based alloys

    Recently, the research team of Yang Shanglu from the Laser Intelligent Manufacturing Technology R&D Center of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Shanghai Institute of Optics and Precision Machinery has made new progress in laser welding of new structural materials for high-temperature molten salts. The research team used a high-power laser for the first time to achieve defect free welding of nick...

    2023-09-01
    See translation
  • Data from the 2023/2024 fiscal year of Tongkuai Group shows a decline in sales and order volume

    German high-tech company TRUMPF has released data for the 2023/24 fiscal year: sales decreased by 3.6% to 5.2 billion euros, and orders decreased by 10.4% to 4.6 billion euros. The global number of employees has increased by 650, with a total of over 19000 employees, and the number of employees in Germany has increased by nearly 400.As of June 30, 2024, at the end of the 2023/24 fiscal year, the s...

    2024-10-21
    See translation
  • Widely tunable terahertz laser enhances photo induced superconductivity in K3C60

    Researchers at the Max Planck Institute for Material Structure and Dynamics (MPSD) in Hamburg, Germany, have long been exploring the effect of using custom laser drivers to manipulate the properties of quantum materials to deviate from equilibrium states.One of the most eye-catching demonstrations of these physics is unconventional superconductors, where enhanced electron coherence and super trans...

    2023-10-13
    See translation
  • Laser printing on fallen leaves can produce sensors for medical and laboratory use

    The manufacturing of sensors through 3D printing combines speed, design freedom, and the possibility of using waste as a substrate. In the circular economy model, various results have been achieved, and typically discarded residues are used as low-cost resources. A research team in Brazil has proposed a highly creative solution that involves printing electrochemical sensors on fallen leaves. The t...

    2024-05-16
    See translation